Saturday, November 2, 2024

Answering the big questions around Deshaun Watson’s injury

November 3, 2017 by  
Filed under Latest Lingerie News

Comments Off

9:55 PM ET

If you’re an NFL fan with a pulse, your heart sank a bit on Thursday as you read about Deshaun Watson going down for the year with a torn ACL. Every injury is bad, of course, but Watson may very well have been the most pleasant surprise of an often-dour 2017 season. As an exciting young player playing in a city that has been through a roller coaster through tragedy to the joy of Wednesday night’s World Series victory, there might be no player in the league neutral fans would have wanted to see stay healthy more than Clemson’s national champion quarterback.

Watson’s injury raises all kinds of questions. Let’s try and answer a few of them here.

Is there a rash of injuries going around the NFL this season?

It’s difficult to say. The attrition rate in the NFL is remarkably and frustratingly high on a year-to-year basis, of course, but it’s fair to wonder if this season seems particularly bad. As I mentioned when I was recording my podcast with Mina Kimes, all you need to do to imagine an injury crisis in the NFL is to watch one or two commercial breaks during an NFL game. You’re bound to see ads with Odell Beckham Jr., Aaron Rodgers, and J.J. Watt, two of whom are done for the year with the other out indefinitely (Rodgers).

In terms of quarterbacks, let’s try to contextualize the problem. As of Week 9, there are six starting signal-callers on the shelf: Watson, Rodgers, Sam Bradford, Andrew Luck, Carson Palmer, and Ryan Tannehill. Jay Cutler, filling in for Tannehill, would qualify as the seventh if he’s unable to play Sunday.

That’s a high number, but not remarkably so. Last season in Week 9, for example, four starting quarterbacks were out injured: Cutler, Robert Griffin, Tony Romo, and Alex Smith, the latter of whom would return the following week. At this time 10 years ago, in a 2007 season held up as the peak of football, six would-be starters were out of the lineup. A 1988 Washington Post article complaining about the lack of available quarterbacks noted how 18 passers had gone down with injuries by the end of Week 6, although some of them were not starters.

Strictly as a passer, Watson was fifth in passer rating and seventh in the league in ANY/A, but even that sells him short. He had drawn eight pass interference calls for a league-leading 173 yards of hidden offense. Watson had thrown eight interceptions, but most of them had come in irrelevant or hopeless situations, as five of them changed Houston’s win expectancy by 2.4 percent or less.

Watson threw 204 passes before suffering his knee injury in practice on Thursday. We have to adjust quarterback stats for the era in which they came, which Pro Football Reference does with its index statistics, as 100 represents era-adjusted league-average.

Ninety-eight quarterbacks have thrown 200 passes or more during their debut campaigns since the merger. Of those 98 passers, Watson posted the best touchdown percentage index (152), the fourth-best yards per attempt index (124), and the ninth-best adjusted yards per attempt index (113). The closest rookie quarterback Watson resembles is Mark Rypien, who was actually making his debut in 1988 after two seasons on injured reserve. Rypien started six games during his rookie campaign, and their era-adjusted stats are remarkably similar: